Legal Challenges

Applicant	Main Issues	Position
Central Craigavon Limited	Alleged failure to grant an adjournment of the public inquiry in relation to a planning application by Sprucefield Centre Limited.	2 June 2010 Application for leave to apply for judicial review. 17 June 2010 Application dismissed.
Bow Street Mall Limited	Alleged decision, express or implied, not to adjourn the inquiry due to commence on 7 June 2010.	2 June 2010 Application for leave to apply for judicial review. 17 June 2010 Application dismissed.
Mrs M Walsh	That the Commission decision in appeal 2007/A0778 is incorrect.	08 March 2010 Application for Judicial Review. 26 April 2010 Commission decision quashed.
Mr P McGlade	That the Commission decision in appeal 2007/A1181 is incorrect.	4 November 2009 Application for Judicial Review. 9 December 2009 Application allowed. Commission decision quashed by agreement.
Mr C Loughran	That Commission decision in appeal 2007/A0433 is incorrect.	2 October 2009 Application for Judicial Review. 13 November 2009 Application allowed. Commission decision quashed by agreement.
Mr F Rafferty	That Commission decision in Appeal 2007/A0321 is incorrect.	24 July 2009 Application for Judicial Review. 17 September 2009 Application allowed. Commission decision quashed by agreement.
Mr P Clarke	That Commission decision in Appeal 2007/E061 is incorrect.	01 May 2009 Application for Judicial Review. 22 June 2009 Application dismissed.
Mrs Kathleen McConalogue	That Commission decision in appeal 2007/E053 is incorrect.	20 April 2009 Application dismissed.
Heron Property Ltd	That Commission decision in Appeal 2006/A1563 is incorrect.	30 March 2009 Application for Judicial Review. 28 September 2009 Application allowed. Decision quashed and remitted to the Commission to consider only the materiality and weight to be accorded to draft PPS 21.
Anderson Haulage Limited	That Commission decision in Appeal 2007/IP001 is incorrect.	27 March 2009 Application for Judicial Review. 17 November 2009 Application allowed. Commission decision quashed and remitted.
Mr A Hyde	That Commission decisions in Appeals 2007/LDC002 and 2007/E035 are incorrect.	27 March 2009 Application for Judicial Review 17 June 2009 Application dismissed.
Thompson Recycled Oil	That Commission decision in appeal 2008/IP003 is incorrect.	9th March 2009 Application for Judicial Review. 2nd October 2009 Application dismissed.
Mr John Boswell	That Commission decision in appeal 2006/A1986 is incorrect.	2nd March 2009 Application for Judicial review. 1 December 2009 Commission decision quashed and remitted.
KPL Contracts Limited	That decision is incorrect in law.	14 March 2008 Application allowed Commission decision quashed by agreement.
Tyr-Arm Ltd	That relevant considerations not taken into account.	7 February 2008 Application allowed. Commission decision quashed by agreement.
Victor Christie (Judicial Review)	That Commission decision in appeal 2006/A0423 was incorrect.	7 January 2008 Leave refused.
R. Thompson (Judicial Review)	That the decision is unfair, illegal and irrational. ECHR rights not considered, insufficient reasons.	03 August 2007 Application Withdrawn.
William Young (Judicial Review)	Apparent bias as Commissioner had considered an earlier appeal in the case.	30 March 2007 High Court, PAC decision quashed. 6 September 2007 Court of Appeal, appeal allowed, PAC decision confirmed. 9 November 2007 Leave refused to appeal to House of Lords